Caribbean Life: Your community, your news.Caribbean Life: Your community, your news.
  • Jobs
  • New York
  • Caribbean
  • Things to Do
    • Local Events
    • Post an Event
    • Business Events
  • Sports
  • Arts
  • Contact Us
  • Digital Editions
  • Podcasts
  • Jobs
Caribbean Life: Your community, your news.Caribbean Life: Your community, your news.
  • Jobs
  • New York
  • Caribbean
  • Things to Do
    • Local Events
    • Post an Event
    • Business Events
  • Sports
  • Arts
  • Contact Us
  • Digital Editions
  • Podcasts
  • Jobs
Caribbean Life: Your community, your news.Caribbean Life: Your community, your news.
  • Things to Do
  • Local Events
  • Post an Event
  • Business Events
  • Jobs
  • New York
  • Caribbean
  • Sports
  • Arts
  • Contact Us
  • Digital Editions
  • Podcasts
  • Jobs
Guest Perspective

Op-ed | New York City’s broken property tax system

By Martha Stark Posted on January 8, 2024
Co-founder of Tax Equity Now New York (TENNY) Martha Stark.
Courtesy of NYU Wagner

For decades, it has been an open secret that New York City’s property tax system is inequitable and unfair. This regressive system, rooted in outdated and discriminatory policies, has not only exacerbated the housing crisis but also deepened the economic divide, disproportionately burdening lower-income and minority communities.  

Next week, New York’s Court of Appeals will hear arguments on a case brought by Tax Equity Now New York (TENNY), a coalition of renters, owners, civic leaders, and public policy and social justice organizations, that challenges NYC’s broken property tax system.

TENNY’s lawsuit was born out of necessity. After decades of widespread acknowledgment of the system’s failings, political leaders at both the city and state levels have repeatedly failed to act.

Close

Stay Connected to the Caribbean

Get the latest news and updates delivered to your inbox.
Thank you for subscribing!

NYC’s current property tax system is a failure on multiple fronts: it’s discriminatory and regressive and violates the principle of uniform assessment. As a matter of law, properties within each of the City’s four tax classes should be assessed at a uniform share of its value. In practice, however, homes in certain well-off neighborhoods in Brooklyn and Manhattan are artificially assessed and taxed at far lower rates than some neighborhoods within those boroughs and lower than neighborhoods in Staten Island, the Bronx, and Queens. The practice shifts the tax burden to those who can scarcely afford it.

This is not just an abstract injustice; it’s a tangible harm that affects thousands of New Yorkers, from small homeowners to tenants who bear the hidden cost in their monthly rent.

Beyond fiscal disparity, this broken system threatens the fabric of our city, making it increasingly difficult for working-class families, essential workers, and communities of color to afford housing. Property taxes––one of the most significant expenses for small homeowners––are driving away the very people who form the backbone of our city. If we continue on this path, we risk losing the economic and cultural diversity that defines New York City, turning it into a place where only the wealthy can reside.

The case TENNY brought is not just about numbers on a tax bill; it’s about the principles of fairness and equity, and the need to put fairness over political convenience. It’s a fight to ensure that NYC’s property tax system doesn’t penalize you based on where you live or the value of your neighborhood.

Our vision is clear: a property tax system that is equitable, transparent, and fair––one that can serve as a model for cities across the nation. We envision a system where taxes are based on actual market values, not convoluted formulas that stoke inequities. We seek an end to the arbitrary penalization of communities, ensuring that all neighborhoods are taxed fairly and justly.  It’s time to replace a broken system with one that reflects the values of our city.

Martha Stark is a tax policy expert and serves as the policy director of Tax Equity Now New York, a coalition that has sued New York State and City, claiming that the property tax structure violates the Constitution and various tax laws. The former commissioner of the New York City Department of Finance, she now serves as clinical professor of practice at NYU’s Robert F. Wagner Graduate School of Public Service. 

About the Author

More in Guest Perspective

  • MTA Chair and CEO Janno Lieber, Construction and Development President Jamie Torres-Springer and Chief Accessibility Officer Quemuel Arroyo announce the next 12 subway stations that will receive ADA upgrades during a press conference at the Franklin Av-Medgar Evers College Station on the 2/3/4/5 lines on Tuesday, July 22, 2025. Making public transit more accessible for all New Yorkers
  • Mayor Eric Adams. Community Op-Ed: Delivering universal after-school care for working families
  • Mayor Eric Adams speaks at the Billie Holiday Theatre in Restoration Plaza on July 28, 2022 in the Bedford-Stuyvesant neighborhood of Brooklyn borough in New York City Community Op-Ed: The most pro-housing administration in city’s history
  • Gov. Kathy Hochul rode the A train in the Rockaways on May 19, 2025. Op-Ed | The MTA is finally getting the investment it needs to move forward

Caribbean events in NYC

Post an Event

The Diary of Yoko Moriwaki is a new play
Aug. 6, 7 pm

The Diary of Yoko Moriwaki
The Producers Club Theaters & Bar

Join us for performances at Forest Park
Aug. 7, 7 pm

Performances & Music at Forest Park Bandshell
Forest Park Bandshell

Brunch 101 is an immersive, university-s
Aug. 9, noon

Brunch 101: An Immersive Boozy Brunch Experience
Brunch 101

Join us for preshow classes and performa
Aug. 9, 5 pm

Performances at Socrates Sculpture Park LIC
Socrates Sculpture Park

Join us for performances at the Unispher
Aug. 10, 6 pm

Performances at the Unisphere
Unisphere at Flushing Meadows Corona Park

Ghost Writer, an Abolitionist’s Tale is
Aug. 13, 2 pm

Ghost Writer, An Abolitionist’s Tale Premieres at Broadway Bound Theatre Festival
AMT Theater

Join us for dance and music performances
Aug. 17, 4 pm

Performances & Music at Corona Plaza
Corona Plaza

Masqueraders painting powder jump up Bay
Aug. 23, all day

Queens Carnival
DredSurfer Grill Restaurant

View All Events…

Jobs in New York

Add your job

  • Strong Place Day CareCook for daycare
  • Innovative Audio Bookkeeper
  • Haas MediaBrooklyn Community Construction Liaison (CCL)

View all jobs…

From Around the Caribbean

  • Guyanese pilot survives serious crash in Turks and Caicos
  • Family members and friends gathered on July 13, 2025, to honor outstanding students at the 4th Annual Empowering Dreams Across Borders: The McGowan Foundation, Inc. Dream big: McGowan Foundation awards bright futures at 4th Annual Gala
  • Grenada's Prime Minister Dickon Mitchell addresses the opening of the 4th Annual AfriCaribbean Trade and Investment Forum in St. George, Grenada on Monday, July 28, 2025. Turning the tide
  • Roniesia Godfrey hosted a launch event featuring some of Guyana’s top female influencers. The signature experience included a city tour of Georgetown, a sunset river cruise on the Demerara River, and a culinary showcase with Chef Dustin, who introduced Guyana-inspired sushi. Roniesia Godfrey is redefining luxury tourism with All Access Guyana
  • NEW YORK, NEW YORK - SEPTEMBER 23: Prime Minister of Grenada The Hon. Dickon Mitchell attends the 2024 Concordia Annual Summit at Sheraton New York Times Square on Sept. 23, 2024 in New York City. Caribbean RoundUp

Get Caribbean Life in your inbox

Close

Get the latest news and updates delivered to your inbox.
Thank you for subscribing!

Submit an Event

Got a hot tip for our calendar? Tell us about it!

Submit now!

New York Local

  • New York State Attorney General Letitia James speaks at a news conference in New York, U.S., June 11, 2019. James welcomes court order upholding birthright citizenship
  • Jean Joseph gives acceptance speech as president of the Brooklyn Canarsie Lions for a fourth term. Four-time leader: Jean Joseph sworn in again as Lions Club president
  • Jamaica Consul General to NY Alsion Wilson addresses the official launching of the Caribbean Diaspora United in June 2024 in honor of Caribbean-American Heritage Month at Russo's on the Bay in Howard Beach, Queens. Jamaica Consulate NY announces independence anniversary celebrations
  • From left, First Deputy Commissioner NYPD, Tonia Kinsella of Guyanese lineage, Chief Technology Officer for New York Matthew C. Fraser, of Guyanese lineage, Mayor Eric L. Adams, Consul General to New York, Michael E. Brotherson, honorees Claire Patterson-Monah, Sherif Fraser, Isiah Chappelle, and Elton Dharry, holding Citation, during a dynamic heritage reception on July 22, at Gracie Mansion in Manhattan. Mayor Adams honors five, applauds Guyanese values at dynamic Gracie Mansion gathering
  • Governor Kathy Hochul unveils Liberty Landing, a transformative project to convert the state-owned 100,000 square-foot former Bayview Correctional Facility in Manhattan into affordable housing for low-income residents and supportive housing for formerly incarcerated individuals reentering the community. The proposed project, a joint venture between Camber Property Group and Osborne Association, would invest over $108 million in West Chelsea and provide 124 permanently affordable housing units and on-site supportive services. Hochul highlights STAR Tax Relief for millions of New Yorkers

Caribbean events in NYC

Find a Job in New York

More from Around NYC

PR 073025 55
Bronx Times

AM Tapia awards $20K to Bronx supportive housing

An 18-year-old from Springfield Gardens was sentenced Friday for causing the death of a 14-year-old girl who was riding in his car during a chain reaction collision and was ejected from the vehicle.
QNS

Queen teen driver sentenced on manslaughter, assault charges for killing 14-year-old girl in gruesome collision: DA

PR 073025 55
PoliticsNY

AM Tapia awards $20K to Bronx supportive housing

Frankie Montas Mets: Man in grey baseball uniform walks off field with hand on chest.
amNY

The Mets have a serious starting pitching problem

  • Newsletter
  • Contact Us
  • Networking Events
  • Home Pros
  • Advertise
  • © 2025 Schneps Media
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Sections
  • Jobs
  • Games
  • Events
  • Contact